| User Submission: |
Dear Editor My Name is Mike and my e-mail address is (with Editor)Tottehnam numbers. Where's David Bentley? Where's Teemu Tainio?
|
| Editor Action : |
Fee amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Paul and my e-mail address is (with editor). I have noticed an error in the the details for Tottenham Hotspur. The details for Sebastien Bassong are incorrect. The fee for Bassong was £8m, not £10m |
| Editor Action : |
Fee amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
Dear Editor My Name is Paul and my e-mail address is with Editor. I have noticed an error in the the details forTottenham Hotspur. The details for Entire 08/09 season are incorrect. They should read You have incorrectly calculated the amount spent by Tottenham in the 08/09 season. The amounts that you've stated total £74.5m, whereas you've listed it as £128.5m.
|
| Editor Action : |
Mistake rectified. Typo when entering the forumla for calculations, Thank you for bringing this to my attaention. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Michael and my e-mail address is (with editor). I have noticed an error in the the details forLiverpool. The details for Aquilani are incorrect. The liverpool echo reported that the fee was in fact 20m euro (£17.1m). They reported that the Roma website had stated this. Therefore I believe that this is the most accurate valuation of the transfer . |
| Editor Action : |
Fee amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is James and my e-mail address is (with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details forArsenal. The details for Steve Sidwell are incorrect.You have no fee against Sidwell. I believe that Arsenal sold him for an small fee of £250,000. Good site. Well done.
|
| Editor Action : |
Fee amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is RAKESH and my e-mail address is (with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details forArsenal. The details for David Bentley are incorrect. You have not included the sell-on fee that Arsenal got when he moved to Spurs for £16. |
| Editor Action : |
Fee amended. I am happy to include sell on fees when they are well documented as is the case for Bentley |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Maciej and my e-mail address is (with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details for Liverpool. The details for Glen Johnson are incorrect. It was not 18,5 mln. My information says a little less. |
| Editor Action : |
Fee amended. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Sam and my e-mail address is (with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details for Liverpool. The details for Batch of players are incorrect. They should read
Arbeloa - 2.64m not 2.6 Glenn Johnson - 17.5 not 18.5 Robbie Keane - 19m not 20.3m Skrtel - 6.5m not 6m .
|
| Editor Action : |
Fees amended . Wikipedia is not viewed as a reliable source for the Glen Johnson fee but in this case the £17.5 million fee has also been reported by the BBC. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Michael and my e-mail address is (with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details forLiverpool. The details for Glen Johnson are incorrect. The figure has been reported as £17m by several newspapers and not the £18.5m given by The Times . |
| Editor Action : |
The Fee recorded has been amended using the BBC as the source. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is jim and my e-mail address is (with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Tottenham Hotspur. The details for klinsmann are incorrect. I cant find him? |
| Editor Action : |
Player added to database. (He was only on loan for his second spell so that is not recorded |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Harry and my e-mail address is (with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Chelsea. The details for Andy Dow are incorrect. Re: Andy Dow, he departed Chelsea for Hibs in March 1996 for £125,000 according to Mark Worral, a published author on Chelsea in the 70s-90s. You don't have any record of his leaving. A web page exists to that effect - see below. I'll update you with any more I may find. |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Sam and my e-mail address is (with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details for Tottenham Hotspur. The details for Roman Pavlyuchenko are incorrect. Roman Pavlyuchenko's sizable transfer not entered . |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Mark and my e-mail address is (with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Arsenal. The details for J Reyes are incorrect. They should read I believe the fee received for Jose Reyes was 8.1 mill. |
| Editor Action : |
Wikipedia is not considered as a reliable source for Transfer fees. I have searched for details on this transfer and numerous independent sources quote a fee of around £8.1 million. I have altered the database to include this fee. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Huw and my e-mail address is (with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Manchester United. The details for Giuseppe Rossi are incorrect. Saw you didn't have any mention of him on your site when United paid £200,000 for him . |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Ashley and my e-mail address is (with editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Tottenham Hotspur. The details for Nick Barmby are incorrect. We didn't buy Barmby in 95, he signed with us when he left school on a free . |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is danny and my e-mail address is (with editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Chelsea. The details for Ben Sahar are incorrect. They should read Sahar cost 320k pound not 3.2m pound . |
| Editor Action : |
Wikipedia is not accepted as a reliable source for transfer fees. I have found another source to support your submission. Recorded fee altered . |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Darren and my e-mail address is (with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Liverpool. Your effort in producing the site is to be commended but after studying your figures I would have to question the accuracy of a lot of your figures having kept records of transfers myself as & when they happen. I find my independent figures collate very well with the figures contained within a good source for historical information regarding Liverpool FC,. Here you will find details of every transfer ever made in Liverpool Football Clubs history. You should visit the site as you will find it will give you some more accurate figures & the make up of the total as well as some figures you do not have. Other clubs may have similar resources available on the internet.
Here is a summary using lfchistory.net figures which I am in agreement about :
1.Robbie Keane – Deal was £19m plus add-ons relating to success & performance to £20.3m. I think it is now safe to assume he will not achieve those add-ons!
2.Robbie Keane – to Spurs. Deal was £16m rising to £19m relating to winning silverware with Spurs. He is in a position to achieve those add-ons.
3.Peter Crouch – Deal was worth £11m, £8.75m rising to £11m.
4.Fernando Torres - £20.2m or £20m The Luis Garcia was not part of this deal. Stated repeatedly by the club at the time that these were two separate, unrelated deals. Also supported by fact Torres took a pay cut to move which is supported by his recent contract renegotiation.
5.Gabriel Paletta - £1.2m to Boca Juniors with LFC retaining 50% of his economic rights & allowing LFC permission to turn Insua loan into permanent deal
6.Lucas Leiva – signed for £5m
7.Alou Diarra – omitted from your list. Transferred out for £2m 2005
8.Mark Gonzalez – Bought for £1.5m 2005/06 & sold for £3.5m 2007/08
9.Antonio Nunez – Sold for £2m 2005/06
10.Michael Owen - £8.5m received
As a side note they make Liverpool’s net spend since start of premiership at under £180m.
Since Rafael Benitez took charge their net spend is £96,291,000 (Spend £189,866,000 + £14,500,000 for Cisse – Received £108,075,000).
As the phone-in crowd are now referencing your site, I hope this is of help to you in maintaining accuracy.
|
| Editor Action : |
I am aware of LFC History.net, however in the interest of maintaining accuracy I do not use club fan sites as a source for transfer fees. If you wish to submit independent links to support your figures I will be happy to investigate.
Re the Torres deal, Rafa stated in an interview that Garcia was part of the Torres deal.
|
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Darren and my e-mail address is (with editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Manchester United. Some details are incorrect. I have viewed your site after it was referenced on Talksport. I Noticed a trend in this clubs figures – very conservative estimates when compared to other clubs estimated transfer values of undisclosed fees. This club has money to spend & are enjoying the success that comes with it. There is no shame attached to this. The only embarrassment is when you don’t admit it. |
| Editor Action : |
1. Ljajic & Tosic £5m each.
Editor: Where the relevant information is available Clauses are not included until theu have been met. See Wayne Rooney and Michael Carrick. Recorded fee not altered
2. Nani £13.5m –£17.3m
Editor: Link Not Working Recorded fee not altered
3. Anderson £15m - £18m
Editor: Fan Sites are not considered as a reliable source for Transfer fees. Recorded fee not altered
4. Hargreaves £17m - £20.2m incl.
TEditor: The links you provided which work refer to speculation before the transfer went through. The links below are from reliable sources and support the £17 million pound fee listed in the database
Recorded feee not altered
5. Heinze £8m – Undisclosed fee.
Editor: Speculation. No link provided, Manchester United obviously did have a say in where he went as he was under contract to them. Recorded fee not altered
6. Gibson – omitted.
Editor: Darron Gibson came through uniteds youth acadamy. No Link provided for a fee.
Recorded fee not altered
|
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Alex (Details with Editor) and my e-mail address is (Details with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details for Chelsea. The details for Adrian Mutu are incorrect. They should read Adrian Mutu was sacked by Chelsea for breach of his contract after failing a drugs test. However, he was ordered to pay Chelsea £13.68M for breaching his contract. This was a recoup of the transfer that Chelsea had payed for Mutu. |
| Editor Action : |
I have investigated this compensation claim. The latest details I can find is that player has lodged an appeal against the compensation award. I will review this in the future when I can source accurate information about Mutu refunding his fee. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Patrick and my e-mail address is(details with Editor) The details for lots in chelsea are incorrect. They should read
1 Chelsea paid 16m for mikel 2 5m in part exchange for a. cole 3 320,000 for sahar 4 1m for lass 5 300,000 for sinclair that could rise to 1m 6 $7m for jiri jarosik
that's a total of 30m missing quite a large number. also man utd only paid 2m for tevez loan .
|
| Editor Action : |
John Obi Mike entry changed to £ 16 million, £ 4 million to Lyn and £12 million to manchester united I have changed Chelsea's entry for Cole from signed to £5 Million . I have changed Chelsea's entry for for sahar to £320.000 I have changed Chelsea's entry for lassana diara to £1 000 000 I have changed Chelsea's entry for sinclair to £300,000 I have change Chelsea's entry for jiri jarosik to £ 3000000 ($7m)
I will investigate the Tezez loan deal further as you did not supply a link .
|
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Ralph (details with Editor) and my e-mail address is (details with Editor). I have noticed an error in the the details for Manchester United. The details for Wayne Rooney are incorrect. They should read Transfer fee given as £25M, whereas sources say this rises to anywhere between £27M to £31M. Other fees on the site (e.g. Torres) are given as the maximum, so for a realistic comparison, so should Rooney's. . |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Ed and my e-mail address is(details with Editor) I have noticed the details for Sean Davis, Pedro Mendes, Noe Pamarot are incorrect. They should read Pompey players - 3 brought in on joint deal costing 7.5m . |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Ralph (details with Editor) and my e-mail address is (details with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Liverpool. The details for Lucas Leiva are incorrect. They should read Transfer fee listed as £9M, when it was actually £5M. |
| Editor Action : |
I have altered the league to put Lucas Levia's fee at £ 6 million . The source for my initial figures was lucasleiva.net which had his fee at €12 million which is where I got the £9 million quoted. I now believe this site is incorrect and £6 million is the accurate figure. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is A F and my e-mail address is(details with Editor) You've got Karl heinz Riedle listed twice as signing for Liverpool..
|
| Editor Action : |
Database amended. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is David (details with Editor) and my e-mail address is (details with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Liverpool. The details for Lucas Leiva are incorrect. I'm a Manchester United fan but in order for your figures to be credible in an argument you need to change the Lucas figure from £9m to £6m.
Rest looks spot on though - good job! Bit of confusion perhaps with the Torres figure where you've listed it as £26m including £4m for Luis Garcia, and also included the Garcia fee in the sales.
|
| Editor Action : |
I have altered the league to put Lucas Levia's fee at £ 6 million . The source for my initial figures was lucasleiva.net which had his fee at €12 million which is where I got the £9 million quoted. I now believe this site is incorrect and £6 million is the accurate figure.
|
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is peter (details with Editor) and my e-mail address is (details with Editor) You don't show the sale value of Arjen Robben by Chelsea 2 years ago, why not as it would offer s gross increase in sales and reduction in per season net average? |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended . |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
My Name is Andy and my e-mail address is (details with Editor) I have noticed an error in the the details for Liverpool. The details for Steve Finnan are incorrect. They should read Steve Finnan was sold to Espanyol of Spain for an undisclosed fee, believed to be around £1M on the 1st September 2008. |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended . |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
The Entry for sami Nasri Of Arsenal Is duplicated
|
| Editor Action : |
Database amended. |
| |
|
| User Submission: |
The fee for Dietmar Hamann of Liverpool is entered as £800 000, it should be £8 000 000 |
| Editor Action : |
Database amended . |
| |
|
| |
|